Advance care planning is the process of thinking about, discussing, and documenting the health care a person would want if illness or injury later prevents them from communicating or making decisions. While decision-making capacity exists, people can name a trusted health care agent, explain their values and preferences, and complete relevant legal documents. This planning matters because incapacity can follow a sudden event as well as a gradual illness: a 2023 national survey found that only about one-third of U.S. adults had an advance directive. This article explains how advance care planning works, what documents and conversations can help, how capacity affects planning, and practical steps for putting preferences into action.
Advance Care Planning as a Health Care Preparation Process
Advance care planning (ACP) is an ongoing process of reflecting on health care values, communicating them to others, and recording preferences so they can guide decisions if a person later cannot make or express them. The National Institute on Aging describes it as planning for future medical care, including choosing someone to make decisions and documenting wishes. ACP is not limited to completing a form, and it does not require a person to refuse treatment.
The process is relevant across adulthood, although serious illness, surgery, a new diagnosis, or changing family circumstances can make it especially timely. In a 2023 study published in the journal Health Affairs, researchers reported that 32.9% of U.S. adults had an advance directive. That finding points to a gap between the importance of planning and its completion. The figure also reflects a particular survey and definition; rates can vary by population and by whether studies count any written directive, a health care proxy, or other planning documents.
Values-based planning
Values-based planning begins with what makes life meaningful to the person, rather than trying to predict every possible medical scenario. A person might discuss independence, comfort, communication, religious or cultural practices, acceptable levels of dependence, and what outcomes would be intolerable. These priorities give a future decision-maker useful context when clinicians face circumstances that a form could not anticipate.
A continuing conversation, not a one-time form
ACP can be revisited as health, relationships, and preferences change. A directive completed years ago may still matter, but it should be reviewed to confirm that the named agent is willing and available and that the document reflects current wishes. The National Institute on Aging recommends sharing plans with the chosen agent, family or other trusted people, and health care professionals, rather than keeping documents inaccessible.
Decision-Making Capacity and Advance Care Planning
Decision-making capacity is a person’s ability to make a particular decision at a particular time. It is not identical to a diagnosis, age, or legal status. The American Bar Association and the American Psychological Association’s handbook on capacity emphasizes that the relevant abilities commonly include understanding information, appreciating how it applies to one’s situation, reasoning about options, and communicating a choice. Clinical assessment depends on the decision and circumstances; legal standards and terminology can vary by jurisdiction.
Planning while capacity exists lets a person speak for themselves before a future crisis may place decisions in someone else’s hands. It is important not to assume that a person with dementia, a psychiatric condition, or a communication disability automatically lacks capacity. Capacity can fluctuate, and support—such as plain-language explanations, interpreters, assistive communication, or a quieter setting—may help a person participate.
Capacity is decision-specific and can change
A person may be able to decide where to live but need support to understand a complex treatment choice, or may have clearer decision-making at some times than others. Clinicians should assess the actual decision rather than rely only on a diagnosis or a general impression. When possible, planning discussions should take place at a time when the person can understand and communicate comfortably.
Supported decision-making and communication
Supported decision-making means helping a person understand and express their own choices without replacing their decision-making role. Useful supports may include accessible explanations, additional time, a trusted supporter chosen by the person, hearing or vision aids, and communication devices. These steps can make ACP more inclusive, particularly for people with disabilities or language-access needs.
Advance Care Planning Documents and Their Uses
Advance care planning documents are written tools that communicate choices or delegate authority. Their names, formal requirements, and legal effects differ by state or country, so people should check local rules. The National Institute on Aging and the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization describe several commonly used forms of documentation; no single document replaces a conversation with the person who may need to act.
Health care proxy or durable power of attorney for health care
A health care proxy document, also called a health care power of attorney in some jurisdictions, names an agent to make medical decisions if the person cannot make them. The agent should be someone who understands the person’s values, can communicate with clinicians, and is willing to follow the person’s wishes even when those wishes differ from the agent’s own preferences. The document may also name an alternate agent and explain when the authority begins.
Living will or advance directive
A living will records preferences for certain future medical situations, such as care near the end of life or treatment when recovery is unlikely. “Advance directive” is often used as a broad term that may include both instructions and appointment of an agent. Because a written form cannot cover every clinical situation, specific statements about goals and values can help clinicians and an agent interpret the document.
Medical orders for current treatment preferences
Medical orders such as POLST, MOLST, or similar forms are designed for people with serious illness or frailty and translate current treatment preferences into clinician orders. They are not simply another name for a living will: they are typically completed with a health professional and are intended to guide care across settings, subject to local rules. The National POLST organization stresses that these orders complement, rather than replace, an advance directive and the appointment of a decision-maker.
Choosing and Preparing a Health Care Decision-Maker
A health care agent is the person authorized under applicable law and documentation to make medical decisions when the individual cannot. Choosing an agent is a central part of ACP because the agent may need to interpret preferences amid uncertainty, time pressure, and emotional strain. The choice should be based on trust and communication, not simply family role or proximity.
Qualities to consider when selecting an agent
A suitable agent can listen carefully, ask questions, tolerate disagreement, and represent the person’s wishes rather than substitute personal beliefs. It is helpful to ask the person directly before naming them and to identify an alternate. Some jurisdictions restrict who may serve, so local requirements should be checked when preparing the document.
Preparing the agent for difficult decisions
A document alone may not prepare an agent for the realities of medical decision-making. Discussing likely scenarios, acceptable trade-offs, and the person’s priorities gives the agent a practical guide. The agent should know where documents are stored, how to reach the person’s clinicians, and whether the person has religious, cultural, or personal requests relevant to care.
Discussing Treatment Goals and Translating Preferences into Care
Treatment preferences are most useful when connected to goals of care: what outcomes a person hopes treatment can achieve and what burdens they would accept to pursue them. ACP discussions can cover resuscitation, ventilation, artificial nutrition, comfort-focused care, and other interventions, but choices should be considered in context with clinicians who can explain likely benefits, burdens, and uncertainties. A preference may reasonably differ depending on the illness, prognosis, and chance of recovery.
Discussing scenarios without trying to predict everything
Instead of treating a form as a checklist of isolated procedures, people can ask what a treatment is intended to accomplish and how it could affect daily life. For example, a person might say they would accept a time-limited trial of intensive treatment if there were a meaningful chance of returning to a life they value, while prioritizing comfort if recovery became very unlikely. This kind of explanation helps an agent apply preferences to circumstances not explicitly named in a document.
Sharing, storing, and reviewing the plan
A plan should be available when needed. Provide copies to the agent and relevant clinicians, ask that the document be added to the medical record, and keep an accessible copy for emergencies. Review it after a major diagnosis, hospitalization, move, marriage or separation, or change in the agent’s availability. The National Institute on Aging advises people to tell family and health care professionals where the documents are kept.
Barriers, Equity, and Practical Ways to Begin
People may delay ACP because they feel healthy, find the topic distressing, are unsure which forms apply, or have difficulty accessing culturally and linguistically appropriate support. Trust in health systems, family expectations, disability access, and differences in state law can also shape the process. Treating planning as a conversation about values and support—not as a prediction of death—can make it easier to begin.
Reducing access and understanding barriers
Health professionals and community organizations can offer plain-language materials, interpreters, accessible formats, and opportunities to discuss choices without pressure. The 2023 advance-directive prevalence estimate of 32.9% also suggests that ACP is not yet routine for many U.S. adults. That national figure does not explain why people have or have not completed documents, but it reinforces the need for clear, broadly accessible support.
A practical first-step checklist
- Think about what matters most for quality of life, independence, comfort, and communication.
- Choose a trusted person and ask whether they are willing to serve as health care agent.
- Discuss values and possible treatment situations with that person and, when useful, a clinician.
- Complete the appropriate documents under local law and consider naming an alternate agent.
- Share copies with the agent and health care team, and review the plan when circumstances change.
Conclusion: Advance Care Planning While Capacity Still Exists
Advance care planning combines values-based conversations, capacity-aware support, legal documents, and practical communication with a chosen decision-maker. A health care proxy can identify who should speak, a living will can record guidance for certain situations, and medical orders may communicate current treatment preferences for people with serious illness. With only about one-third of U.S. adults reporting an advance directive in a 2023 study, there is a clear opportunity to make these discussions more familiar and accessible.
The best time to clarify preferences is before a crisis makes communication difficult. Start with one conversation, ask a trusted person to serve as agent, and consult a clinician or qualified local resource about the documents that apply. Revisit the plan as life and health change so that it remains a useful expression of the person’s choices.
Sources: Yadav, K.N., et al., “Approximately One in Three US Adults Completes Any Type of Advance Directive for End-of-Life Care,” Health Affairs, 2023, https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2023.00292; National Institute on Aging, “Advance Care Planning: Advance Directives for Health Care,” https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/advance-care-planning/advance-care-planning-advance-directives-health-care; American Bar Association and American Psychological Association, Assessment of Older Adults with Diminished Capacity: A Handbook for Psychologists, https://www.apa.org/pi/aging/resources/guides/diminished-capacity.pdf; National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization, “Advance Care Planning,” https://www.nhpco.org/patients-and-caregivers/advance-care-planning/; National POLST, “About POLST,” https://polst.org/about/
